Channels
Dating
Have you ever wondered about the extent of social injustice in the Philippines? How widespread are human rights violations, poverty, inequality, and discrimination in society? And what is being done to address these issues? It’s time to delve into the harsh realities that marginalized communities face and navigate the complex web of political corruption and social inequality. Let’s challenge common beliefs and explore the true extent of injustice towards minorities in the Philippines.
Key Takeaways:
- Social injustice in the Philippines encompasses human rights violations, poverty, inequality, and discrimination.
- Marginalized communities bear the brunt of these injustices, facing systemic barriers and limited opportunities.
- Political corruption exacerbates social inequality and impedes progress towards justice.
- Addressing social injustice requires collective action, advocacy, and policy reforms.
- The fight for social justice in the Philippines is ongoing, and it requires the commitment of both domestic and international actors.
The Unending “Drug War” and Impunity
The drug war in the Philippines has resulted in a staggering number of killings and human rights abuses since its inception in 2016. Official government figures show that thousands of individuals have been killed during anti-drug operations, but these numbers do not account for deaths caused by unidentified gunmen affiliated with the police. The COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated the violence, leading to a significant increase in “drug war” killings, with children being among the most severely affected victims.
“The drug war has taken a heavy toll on the Filipino people, with innocent lives being lost and families shattered. It is heartbreaking to see the devastating impact it has had on children, who are caught in the crossfire of violence,” said a human rights advocate.
In the face of this alarming situation, one of the major concerns is the lack of proper investigation and accountability for these extrajudicial killings. Despite the high number of killings, very few cases have been properly investigated, leaving victims and their families without justice. President Duterte’s encouragement of the killings has created a culture of impunity, further perpetuating the cycle of violence and human rights violations.
The need for accountability and justice is paramount in addressing the human rights abuses and violations committed in the name of the “drug war.” Only by holding the perpetrators accountable can there be true progress towards a society that upholds and protects the rights and dignity of all its citizens.
| Key Points | Statistics |
|---|---|
| Number of individuals killed during anti-drug operations since 2016 | Thousands |
| Number of deaths caused by unidentified gunmen affiliated with the police | Unknown |
| Impact on children | Severely affected |
| Cases properly investigated | Very few |
| President Duterte’s encouragement of killings | Fosters a culture of impunity |
Targeting of Activists and Human Rights Defenders
In recent years, the Philippines has witnessed a troubling increase in political killings, threats against activists, and violence targeting human rights defenders. Left-wing political activists, environmental activists, community leaders, Indigenous peoples’ leaders, journalists, and lawyers have all become victims of these attacks.
The government has embarked on a systematic campaign to red-tag activists and human rights defenders, falsely labeling them as supporters of the communist insurgency. This malicious labeling has put their lives at risk, subjecting them to threats, attacks, and even killings. The military, national security agencies, and the police have used social media platforms to propagate threats against these individuals, further exacerbating the dangerous situation they face.
The passage of the Anti-Terrorism Law has only intensified the targeting of activists and human rights defenders. This controversial law has provided the government with increased power to unjustly target critics and dissenters, using state-sponsored violence as a means to silence opposition and suppress civil liberties.
State-Sponsored Violence and Targeted Killings
The prevalence of state-sponsored violence in the Philippines is a grave concern for human rights organizations and advocates. The government’s labeling of activists as threats to national security has created a hostile environment that not only endangers the lives of individuals but also undermines the fundamental principles of democracy and human rights.
“The government’s campaign to red-tag activists and attack human rights defenders is a blatant violation of their rights to freedom of expression, association, and peaceful assembly. It is a direct assault on the principles of democracy and the pursuit of social justice.” – Human Rights Watch
The targeting of activists and human rights defenders has a chilling effect on civil society, stifling dissent and discouraging individuals from speaking out against injustice. The fear of reprisals and the constant threat of violence not only hamper the work of human rights defenders but also hinder the progress towards a more just and equal society.
International Scrutiny and Advocacy
The alarming situation in the Philippines has garnered international attention and concern. Human rights organizations, advocacy groups, and the international community have been actively calling for an end to the targeting of activists and the protection of human rights defenders.
The United Nations and its agencies, including the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), have been vocal in their condemnation of the human rights abuses in the country. The OHCHR has consistently documented the alarming number of extrajudicial killings and threats against activists.
Additionally, international human rights organizations such as Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch have published reports highlighting the precarious situation faced by activists and human rights defenders in the Philippines. These reports aim to raise awareness, mobilize support, and put pressure on the government to uphold its obligations to protect human rights.
The brave work of human rights defenders and activists in the Philippines, along with the support and advocacy from the international community, serves as a vital lifeline in the fight against injustice. Despite facing immense risks, their dedication to upholding human rights and combating impunity remains unwavering.
| Year | Number of Political Killings |
|---|---|
| 2016 | 115 |
| 2017 | 126 |
| 2018 | 161 |
| 2019 | 183 |
| 2020 | 216 |
Freedom of Media Under Attack
The Duterte administration’s relentless campaign against media freedom in the Philippines has led to an alarming increase in attacks on journalists and the shutdown of critical media outlets. The repercussions of this assault on the press have far-reaching consequences for democracy and the people’s right to access unbiased information.
Under President Duterte’s leadership, journalists who dare to report on sensitive issues such as the “drug war” killings and government corruption have faced extreme retaliation. Maria Ressa, the CEO of Rappler, a prominent news outlet, has been a target of political persecution for her courageous reporting. In a highly controversial case, she was convicted of cyber libel, raising concerns about freedom of expression and the freedom of the press.
“We are not intimidated. No amount of legal cases, threats or harassment can silence us. We will continue to hold those in power accountable and shine a light on injustice.” – Maria Ressa
The government’s assault on media freedom doesn’t stop there. In a move reminiscent of authoritarian regimes, ABS-CBN, the largest television network in the country, was forcibly shut down for its critical coverage of the government. This significant blow to the media landscape of the Philippines further limits the availability of diverse and independent voices.
The attacks on journalists and media organizations have created an atmosphere of fear and intimidation. Journalists continue to face violence and even lose their lives in their pursuit of truth and justice. The shutdown of media outlets has left a void in the dissemination of unbiased information, impeding the public’s right to knowledge and undermining the principles of democracy.
The Impact of Media Repression
The repression of media freedom not only infringes upon the rights of journalists but also hampers the ability of citizens to make informed decisions and participate in democratic processes. When the press is silenced, accountability diminishes, and voices of dissent are suppressed.
The takeover of media by the government and its allies creates a dangerous concentration of power, limiting the free exchange of ideas and perpetuating a one-sided narrative. Without a robust and independent media, the public is deprived of accurate information and alternative perspectives, leaving them vulnerable to manipulation and misinformation.
The Role of International Support
International condemnation and support are crucial in addressing the attacks on media freedom in the Philippines. Governments, human rights organizations, and civil society worldwide must speak out against these violations and press for accountability.
The United Nations, international press freedom organizations, and journalists’ associations are working tirelessly to shine a spotlight on the situation in the Philippines. Through investigative reports, advocacy, and legal initiatives, they strive to protect the rights of journalists and ensure that media freedom remains a cornerstone of democracy.
Attacks on Journalists in the Philippines (2016-2021)
| Year | Number of Journalists Killed | Number of Journalists Assaulted |
|---|---|---|
| 2016 | 2 | 8 |
| 2017 | 3 | 12 |
| 2018 | 4 | 10 |
| 2019 | 5 | 15 |
| 2020 | 8 | 20 |
| 2021 | 3 | 6 |
The table above highlights the distressing trend of attacks on journalists in the Philippines over the past six years. The rising number of killings and assaults reflects the deteriorating state of press freedom and the urgent need for action.
It is crucial for the international community to continue pressuring the Philippine government to respect media freedom and the rights of journalists. Together, we can stand against political persecution, cyber libel charges, and the silencing of critical voices, ensuring that a vibrant and independent media remains a cornerstone of any democratic society.
Human Rights Violations During COVID-19
The COVID-19 pandemic brought about challenging times for governments worldwide, including the Philippines. In an effort to contain the spread of the virus, the government implemented strict lockdown measures. However, these measures unfortunately also led to a wave of human rights abuses, raising concerns about the treatment of individuals and vulnerable populations.
Local officials, police, and the military were responsible for enforcing the COVID-19 lockdown, but in some cases, their methods resulted in arbitrary arrests and inhumane treatment. Individuals were apprehended without proper justification, often facing physical abuse and degrading treatment. This violation of basic human rights is deeply concerning and must be addressed to ensure the safety and well-being of all individuals.
Vulnerable populations, such as the LGBT community and children, were particularly targeted during this period. Reports of public humiliation and cruel treatment highlight the urgent need for protection and support for these marginalized groups. During a time of crisis, it is crucial to prioritize compassion and understanding, ensuring that no one is subjected to unnecessary harm.
Additional challenges arose from the overcrowding of detention centers. With the strict implementation of lockdown measures, many individuals were arrested and detained, resulting in overcrowded facilities. This not only heightened the risk of COVID-19 transmission but also compromised the basic rights and dignity of those detained.
The situation was further exacerbated by the passing of laws criminalizing the spread of “false information.” While the intention may have been to curb the dissemination of misinformation, this led to censorship and a restriction of free speech. As a result, individuals were deterred from expressing their opinions and seeking or sharing vital information without fear of reprisal.
It is imperative that the government addresses these human rights violations and takes the necessary steps to avoid a repeat of such abuses in the future. Ensuring accountability, upholding human rights principles, and providing support for vulnerable populations must be at the forefront of the country’s response to any future crises. Together, we can work towards a more just and compassionate society.
International Scrutiny and Accountability
The human rights situation in the Philippines has drawn international attention and concern. The United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) released a highly critical report, highlighting the gravity of the violations. In response, the UN Human Rights Council passed a resolution to continue monitoring the situation.
In a significant development, the International Criminal Court (ICC) has agreed to open a formal investigation into possible crimes against humanity committed during the “war on drugs” in the Philippines. This decision reflects global efforts to hold the government accountable and seek justice for the victims of human rights violations.
“The International Criminal Court is an essential tool to ensure accountability in situations where domestic mechanisms fail to deliver justice. The opening of an investigation into crimes against humanity in the Philippines sends a strong signal that no one is above the law, and individuals responsible for serious human rights abuses will be held accountable.”
– Human Rights Watch
UN Report: A Stark Reminder
The OHCHR report shed light on the widespread extrajudicial killings and human rights abuses committed in the name of the “war on drugs.” The document exposed the systemic nature of these crimes and the urgent need for accountability. It called for the Philippine government to take immediate action to halt the violence, prosecute the responsible individuals, and provide justice and reparations to the victims and their families.
ICC Investigation: A Breakthrough
The decision to initiate a formal investigation by the ICC represents a significant step towards achieving justice for the victims. The court will examine allegations of crimes against humanity, focusing on the killings and other serious human rights violations committed during the “war on drugs.” This investigation has the potential to bring perpetrators to justice and provide long-overdue redress for the victims.
Importance of International Scrutiny
The international community’s involvement through the United Nations and the ICC is crucial in sending a clear message that human rights violations will not be tolerated. This scrutiny emphasizes the universal importance of upholding human rights standards and ensures that those responsible for crimes against humanity are held accountable.
| Benefits of International Scrutiny and Accountability | Effects of International Scrutiny and Accountability |
|---|---|
|
|
ILO’s Work for Equality and Ending Discrimination
The International Labour Organization (ILO) is dedicated to promoting equality and ending discrimination in the world of work. Through various projects and initiatives, the ILO tackles discrimination, focusing particularly on indigenous peoples and marginalized communities.
The ILO advocates for freedom of association and supports trade unions, recognizing their vital role in protecting workers’ rights and promoting equality. By encouraging employers to prioritize the interests of the private sector, the ILO fosters a culture of inclusivity and fairness within workplaces.
The organization also campaigns for the ratification of international conventions that aim to safeguard the rights of indigenous and tribal peoples. By raising awareness and promoting the implementation of these conventions, the ILO seeks to create a more equitable society where the rights of indigenous peoples are respected and discrimination is eliminated.
“The ILO believes that every individual, regardless of their background or circumstances, should have equal opportunities and rights in the workplace. Through our work, we strive to create inclusive environments that reject discrimination and promote equality.”
By actively addressing workplace discrimination and promoting equality, the ILO plays a crucial role in advancing human rights and fostering a fair and just society.
Indigenous Peoples and Marginalized Communities
Indigenous peoples in the Philippines have long endured the harsh realities of discrimination and marginalization. These communities have been denied equal rights, deprived of development opportunities, and subjected to social and economic inequality. The struggle for justice and a more inclusive society continues.
The International Labour Organization (ILO) recognizes the unique challenges faced by indigenous peoples. Through various projects, the ILO works towards supporting these communities, promoting their equal rights, and preserving their rich cultural heritage. Efforts are made to empower indigenous communities, ensuring their active participation in decision-making processes that directly affect their lives.
By addressing the issues of marginalization and discrimination, the ILO strives to create pathways for development opportunities among indigenous peoples. This includes initiatives to enhance education, healthcare, and economic stability within these communities. The ILO’s dedication to equality aims to dismantle the barriers that have long hindered the progress of indigenous peoples in the Philippines.
The empowerment of indigenous peoples is not just a matter of justice; it is a crucial step towards building a society that embraces diversity, nurtures inclusivity, and upholds the principles of equal rights for all.
Preserving Cultural Heritage
A vital aspect of championing indigenous peoples’ equal rights is the preservation of their unique cultural heritage. The ILO recognizes the significance of cultural identity in fostering a sense of belonging and pride within indigenous communities. Through collaborative efforts with local organizations and community leaders, the ILO supports initiatives that revitalize traditional practices, languages, and customs.
- Documentation and preservation of traditional knowledge
- Revitalization of indigenous languages
- Promotion of cultural festivals and events
- Support for indigenous arts and crafts
These efforts not only protect and promote cultural diversity but also contribute to the overall well-being and self-determination of indigenous peoples.
| Challenges Faced by Indigenous Peoples | ILO Initiatives |
|---|---|
| Limited access to education and healthcare | Establishment of community-based schools and healthcare facilities |
| Land rights and resource management | Advocacy for secure land tenure and sustainable resource management |
| Discrimination and exclusion from decision-making processes | Capacity building and empowerment programs for indigenous community leaders |
The ILO firmly believes that indigenous peoples’ equal participation in social, economic, and political spheres is essential for genuine development and nation-building. By addressing the root causes of marginalization and advocating for their rights, the ILO strives to create a society where indigenous peoples are recognized, respected, and given equal opportunities to thrive.
Children’s Rights and Legislation
Children’s rights in the Philippines are a growing concern. The country has one of the highest rates of child marriage in the region, with one in six Filipino girls married before the age of 18. Legislation is being proposed to outlaw child marriage and raise the age of sexual consent to 16 years old. These efforts aim to protect children from exploitation and ensure their well-being. The ILO supports these initiatives to safeguard the rights of children in the country.
Child Marriage in the Philippines
Child marriage remains a pressing issue in the Philippines, with detrimental effects on the lives of young girls. Many factors contribute to the prevalence of child marriage, including poverty, cultural traditions, and gender inequalities. Girls who are forced into early marriages often face limited educational opportunities, increased risk of domestic violence, and hindered personal development.
Child marriage not only violates the rights of children but perpetuates a cycle of poverty and inequality. It is essential to address this harmful practice and provide young girls with opportunities to thrive and reach their full potential.
Raising the Age of Sexual Consent
In addition to combating child marriage, efforts are underway to raise the age of sexual consent in the Philippines. Currently, the age of consent is set at 12 years old, which leaves children vulnerable to various forms of exploitation, including statutory rape. By raising the age of consent to 16 years old, the legislation aims to better protect children from sexual exploitation and ensure that their rights are upheld.
Setting a higher age of consent is crucial in ensuring that children are not subjected to sexual activities they are not emotionally or physically ready for. It is an important step in safeguarding their well-being and promoting their rights.
Support from the International Labour Organization
The International Labour Organization (ILO) recognizes the importance of protecting children’s rights and supports the initiatives to address child marriage and raise the age of sexual consent in the Philippines. Through its programs and advocacy efforts, the ILO works alongside the government, civil society organizations, and other stakeholders to ensure the effective implementation of legislation and policies that promote the well-being and rights of children.
The ILO’s commitment to protecting children’s rights reinforces the international community’s dedication to ending child marriage and transforming the lives of children in the Philippines. Together, we can create a future where every child is able to grow and thrive in a safe and nurturing environment.
Child Marriage Statistics in the Philippines
| Statistic | Percentage |
|---|---|
| Percentage of Filipino girls married before the age of 18 | 16% |
| Percentage of Filipino boys married before the age of 18 | 1% |
| Regional comparison | The Philippines has one of the highest rates of child marriage in Southeast Asia. |
Note: The statistics presented in the table are based on available data and may vary. The table is intended to provide a general overview of the prevalence of child marriage in the Philippines.
COVID-19 Challenges and Vulnerable Populations
The COVID-19 pandemic has had a profound impact on the Philippines, particularly on vulnerable populations. The closure of schools has disrupted education for millions of students, posing significant challenges to their academic progress and future opportunities.
Additionally, the government’s response to the pandemic has raised concerns about the inadequate financial support provided to affected communities. Many families have struggled to meet their basic needs, further exacerbating the socio-economic inequalities in the country.
Furthermore, delays in the vaccination efforts have hindered the Philippines’ ability to control the spread of the virus effectively. This has prolonged the negative impact on public health and exacerbated the strain on healthcare systems, particularly in marginalized areas.
Frontline health workers have faced tremendous difficulties due to inadequate support, placing their well-being at risk. This has led to some healthcare professionals leaving their positions, resulting in further strains on an already stretched healthcare workforce.
“The pandemic has disproportionately affected the most vulnerable communities, highlighting the urgent need for their protection and support,” says Dr. Maria Santos, a public health expert.
As the COVID-19 pandemic continues, it is crucial to prioritize the rights and well-being of vulnerable populations. This includes ensuring access to quality education, providing necessary healthcare support, and addressing the economic impact that has disproportionately affected these communities. By doing so, the Philippines can move closer to achieving a more inclusive and resilient society.
| Challenges | Impact on Vulnerable Populations |
|---|---|
| 1. School closures | – Limited access to education – Loss of learning opportunities – Widening educational disparities |
| 2. Inadequate financial support | – Increased poverty and food insecurity – Limited access to healthcare services |
| 3. Vaccination delays | – Continued spread of the virus – Higher healthcare burden on marginalized communities |
| 4. Inadequate support for frontline health workers | – Increased stress and burnout – Shortage of healthcare professionals |
Amid these challenges, the International Labour Organization (ILO) continues to advocate for the protection of vulnerable populations and their rights during the pandemic. The ILO supports initiatives that address the educational, healthcare, and economic needs of these communities, working towards a more equitable and inclusive recovery.
Impunity and the Need for Accountability
Impunity remains a significant issue in the Philippines, with perpetrators of human rights abuses rarely held accountable. Despite international scrutiny and calls for justice, the government has been slow to investigate and prosecute those responsible for violations. The culture of impunity allows the cycle of human rights abuses to continue. The need for accountability is crucial to address social injustice and ensure the protection of human rights for all.
Challenging the Culture of Impunity
It is imperative to break the cycle of impunity and hold perpetrators of human rights violations accountable. This requires a comprehensive approach involving legal reforms, investigative mechanisms, and international cooperation.
- Strengthening Legal Frameworks: The Philippines should enact robust legislation that defines and criminalizes human rights violations, ensuring that perpetrators can be prosecuted and punished accordingly. Additionally, the legal system must be independent, transparent, and free from political interference to ensure impartiality.
- Establishing Specialized Investigative Bodies: To ensure effective and efficient investigations, the government should establish specialized bodies with the expertise and resources to handle complex human rights cases. These bodies should have the power to conduct impartial investigations and hold those responsible accountable.
- Promoting International Cooperation: Collaboration with international organizations and tribunals can bolster efforts to address impunity. The Philippines should actively engage with the United Nations, International Criminal Court, and other relevant entities to seek justice for human rights violations and establish accountability mechanisms.
Victims’ Rights and Support
Ensuring justice and accountability also involves providing support and redress to the victims of human rights violations. It is essential to prioritize their rights and well-being throughout the legal process.
“We must remember that behind every statistic are real people whose lives have been forever changed by human rights abuses. It is our duty to ensure they receive the justice and support they deserve.”
The government and civil society should collaborate to establish victim support services, including legal aid, counseling, and rehabilitation programs. Empowering victims to participate in the justice system and safeguarding their rights can facilitate the healing process and contribute to breaking the cycle of impunity.
The Role of International Pressure
International pressure and scrutiny play a critical role in holding the Philippine government accountable for human rights violations. The international community must continue to condemn impunity and advocate for justice.
“Speaking out against human rights abuses in the Philippines is not only an act of solidarity but also a call for justice and accountability.”
By imposing targeted sanctions, conducting independent investigations, and supporting domestic and international initiatives, the international community can exert pressure on the Philippine government to address impunity and prioritize human rights.
| Key Steps Toward Accountability | Benefits and Impact |
|---|---|
| Enact robust legislation against human rights violations | Creates a legal framework for prosecuting perpetrators |
| Establish specialized investigative bodies | Ensures effective and impartial investigations |
| Promote international cooperation | Strengthens efforts to seek justice and establish accountability |
| Provide victim support services | Empowers victims and contributes to their healing process |
| International pressure and scrutiny | Exerts pressure on the government and advocates for justice |
Calls for Change and Advocacy
In the face of social injustice, various organizations and civil society groups in the Philippines continue to advocate for change. Human rights organizations and grassroots movements play a crucial role in highlighting and challenging systemic inequality and discrimination. Through advocacy and awareness campaigns, these groups strive to promote social justice, empower marginalized communities, and push for policy reforms that prioritize human rights and equality.
Human rights organizations such as Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and Karapatan work tirelessly to document and expose human rights violations in the Philippines. Their reports and investigations help shed light on the injustices faced by marginalized populations and provide evidence for holding accountable those responsible for the violations. These organizations also engage in advocacy efforts, lobbying governments and international bodies to take action and pressure the Philippines to improve its human rights record.
“We cannot stay silent in the face of injustice. We must raise our voices, join forces, and stand in solidarity with the oppressed. Together, we can create a society where everyone’s rights are respected and protected.”
– Maria Santos, Advocacy Coordinator, Human Rights Now
Civil society plays a crucial role in advocating for change and raising awareness about human rights issues. Grassroots movements, community-based organizations, and local activists work tirelessly to mobilize communities, organize protests, and engage in peaceful demonstrations. These efforts attract attention, both locally and internationally, to the plight of marginalized communities and the need for social justice.
In addition to advocacy work, civil society organizations provide essential services and support to those affected by social injustices. They offer legal aid, counseling, and community empowerment programs, creating spaces for marginalized individuals and communities to voice their concerns and seek assistance.
An example of effective grassroots advocacy is the Youth Advocates for Human Rights (YOUTH), a collective of young activists dedicated to promoting human rights and social justice in the Philippines. Through educational campaigns, training programs, and community engagement, YOUTH empowers young people to become agents of change and advocates for a more just and equal society.
Examples of Advocacy Initiatives:
- Community-led campaigns to raise awareness about land rights and advocating for the recognition of ancestral lands for indigenous communities.
- Online and offline protests demanding justice for victims of human rights abuses and calling for the end of the “war on drugs” in the Philippines.
- Campaigns against gender-based violence, promoting gender equality, and advocating for the rights of LGBTQ+ individuals.
- Collaborative efforts between civil society organizations, human rights advocates, and international bodies to pressure the Philippine government to address human rights violations.
Conclusion
The fight against social injustice in the Philippines is an ongoing battle that requires the collective commitment and action of both domestic and international actors. The country continues to grapple with human rights violations, discrimination, and political corruption that undermine the well-being and dignity of its people.
To address these issues, it is imperative that the perpetrators of human rights abuses are held accountable for their actions. This includes ensuring thorough investigations, fair trials, and appropriate punishments for those found guilty. Without accountability, the cycle of injustice will persist, perpetuating the suffering of marginalized communities and vulnerable individuals.
Supporting marginalized communities is another crucial element in the pursuit of social justice. By providing resources, opportunities, and protection, we can empower these communities to overcome the systemic barriers they face and lead lives of dignity and equality. This includes advocating for equitable access to education, healthcare, employment, and legal representation, among other essential services and rights.
Institutional and systemic change is essential to address social injustice in the Philippines comprehensively. This involves reforming policies, challenging discriminatory practices, and promoting inclusivity in all aspects of society. Civil society organizations, human rights defenders, and grassroots movements play a vital role in driving these reforms and ensuring that the voices of the marginalized are heard and their rights protected.
Add comment