Channels
Dating
Are you aware of the legal framework that governs corporations in the Philippines? The Corporation Code of the Philippines, also known as Republic Act 11232, is a crucial guide for incorporating and managing businesses in the country. Understanding its provisions is key to ensuring compliance and successful operations. Let’s explore some essential aspects of the code and discover what it means for entrepreneurs, business owners, and investors.
Key Takeaways:
- The Corporation Code of the Philippines (Republic Act 11232) provides guidelines and regulations for corporations in the country.
- Compliance with the code is essential for starting and managing businesses in the Philippines.
- The Revised Corporation Code (RA 11232) simplifies the incorporation process and improves corporate governance standards.
- Notable changes include the creation of One-Person Corporations, the removal of minimum capitalization requirements, and the option for corporations to exist indefinitely.
- The code also introduces provisions for online filings, electronic communication in stockholder meetings, and flexibility in meeting locations.
Criminal Law Principles
In the Philippines, the criminal justice system operates under the doctrine of strict construction of criminal law. This principle ensures that criminal statutes are interpreted narrowly and any doubts or ambiguities in the law are resolved in favor of the accused. The legal maxim “in dubio pro reo” holds that when the law is unclear, the accused should be given the benefit of the doubt.
Under Philippine jurisdiction, a person can only be held criminally liable if their actions are explicitly defined and penalized by the penal code or a special penal law. In the absence of a specific provision, criminal liability cannot be imposed. This safeguards individuals from arbitrary punishments and promotes fairness in the judicial process.
The strict construction of criminal law also necessitates a reasonable and sensible interpretation of the statutes to align with the legislative purpose and intent. This approach ensures that the law is applied in a manner that is just and in accordance with societal norms and values.
Furthermore, in the Philippines, penal statutes are not extended to cover offenses beyond those specifically described and provided for. This principle prevents the prosecution from stretching the boundaries of the law to criminalize conduct that falls outside its intended scope.
“The criminal law of the Philippines is designed to protect individual rights and ensure that defendants are afforded the presumption of innocence until proven guilty. By strictly construing criminal statutes and limiting their applicability, the law strives to achieve a fair and impartial criminal justice system.”
Understanding the principles that govern criminal law in the Philippines is essential for both legal professionals and individuals involved in criminal cases. It ensures that the rights of the accused are protected, promotes a balanced approach to law enforcement, and upholds the integrity of the criminal justice system.
Key Points:
- The Philippines follows the doctrine of strict construction of criminal law, favoring the accused in case of ambiguity.
- Criminal liability can only be imposed if an act is explicitly defined and penalized by the penal code or special penal law.
- Reasonable and sensible interpretation of the law is prioritized to reflect legislative purpose and intent.
- Penal statutes are not extended to cover offenses other than those specifically described and provided for.
All Other Violations of Any Provision of the Revised Corporation Code “Not Specifically Punished”
The Revised Corporation Code introduced significant changes regarding violations of its provisions. While specific penalties are outlined for certain offenses, Section 170 of the Code addresses violations that are not specifically penalized. These violations can lead to criminal penalties in the form of fines ranging from PHP 10,000 to PHP 1,000,000.
It is crucial to note that liability for these violations is separate from any other administrative, civil, or criminal liability under the Code and other laws. The Revised Corporation Code ensures that all violations are treated seriously to maintain the integrity and compliance of corporate entities in the Philippines.
Penalties for Violations
In addition to fines, penalties for violations of the Revised Corporation Code can also involve the dissolution of the corporation. The severity of the penalty will depend on the specific violation and its impact on the operations and stakeholders of the corporation. The imposition of these penalties serves as a deterrent against non-compliance and promotes adherence to the legal and ethical standards upheld by the Code.
Ensuring compliance with the Revised Corporation Code is crucial for businesses operating in the Philippines. By understanding the penalties associated with violations, corporations can take the necessary steps to avoid legal repercussions and maintain a strong foundation for their operations.
Meaning of “Violation of Any Provisions of the Corporation Code” under Section 144
Under the old Corporation Code, Section 144 imposed criminal penalties for violations of any provision of the Code that was not specifically penalized. However, interpreting this provision as encompassing all non-compliance with the Code’s provisions posed challenges. Some provisions in the old Code were intended to impose only civil sanctions or damages.
The Revised Corporation Code clarifies that specific penalties or sanctions provided within a particular provision should take precedence over the general criminal penalty under Section 170.
This clarification ensures a more precise understanding of the consequences for violating the provisions of the Corporation Code. It eliminates ambiguity and aligns with the principle that specific penalties tailored to each provision should prevail over a general criminal penalty. By emphasizing the importance of specific penalties, the Revised Corporation Code promotes clarity, fairness, and accountability within the corporate sector.
By clearly defining the penalties and sanctions for specific violations, the Revised Corporation Code aims to foster a culture of compliance and responsible corporate governance.
Importance of Clarity in Penalties and Sanctions
“Clear and well-defined penalties and sanctions for violating the provisions of the Corporation Code contribute to the promotion of a transparent and law-abiding business environment. By providing specificity, businesses are better equipped to understand the consequences of non-compliance and make informed decisions to ensure adherence to the law.”
| Old Corporation Code | Revised Corporation Code |
|---|---|
| Challenging to interpret Section 144 as all-encompassing | Specific penalties take precedence over general criminal penalty under Section 170 |
| Some provisions intended only civil sanctions or damages | Increased clarity on penalties for specific violations |
| Implied penalties for non-specific violations | Emphasis on tailored penalties for each provision |
Ensuring a clear and comprehensive understanding of the penalties and sanctions for violating the provisions of the Corporation Code is vital for corporate compliance and proper governance. With the Revised Corporation Code’s clarification on specific penalties, businesses can navigate the legal landscape with confidence, promoting ethical practices, and upholding the principles of accountability.
Absence of Malice or Defense of Good Faith
In Philippine jurisdiction, a conviction under the criminal penalty provisions of the Corporation Code would be challenging without establishing malice or the absence of good faith. Even if Section 144 or Section 170 theoretically encompassed every violation, the specific provisions of the Code often provide remedies or civil sanctions for particular offenses. Existing jurisprudence has highlighted the distinction between offenses subject to criminal penalties and those subject to civil remedies within the Code.
| Criminal Penalties | Existing Jurisprudence |
|---|---|
| Section 144 | Establishes general criminal penalty for violations of any provision of the Corporation Code not specifically penalized |
| Section 170 | Specifies the range of fines for violations of the Code, from PHP 10,000 to PHP 1,000,000, and the possibility of dissolution of the corporation |
| Specific Provisions | Many provisions of the Code provide remedies or civil sanctions for particular offenses |
The presence of malice or the absence of good faith is crucial in determining criminal liability under the Corporation Code. While certain offenses may be subject to criminal penalties, other provisions offer alternative resolutions or civil remedies. It is imperative for individuals and corporations to familiarize themselves with the existing jurisprudence surrounding these matters to ensure compliance and mitigate potential criminal liability risks.
Revised Corporation Code of the Philippines Overview
The Revised Corporation Code (RA 11232) was signed into law on February 20, 2019. It aims to enhance the efficiency and accessibility of doing business in the Philippines by simplifying the incorporation process and improving corporate governance standards.
This significant legislative development has implications for both local businesses and foreign investors, providing opportunities for growth and attracting investments.
| Benefits of the Revised Corporation Code | Impacts |
|---|---|
| Simplified company incorporation process | Allows businesses to start operations quickly and efficiently |
| Improved corporate governance standards | Promotes transparency, accountability, and responsible business practices |
Creating a One-Person Corporation
The Revised Corporation Code introduced significant changes to the incorporation process, including the establishment of the One-Person Corporation (OPC). Previously, a minimum of five incorporators was required to register a corporation in the Philippines. However, with the introduction of OPC, a single individual can now establish their own corporation.
The key features of an OPC are designed to accommodate the needs of solo entrepreneurs:
| Key Features of One-Person Corporation (OPC) |
|---|
| The sole incorporator also serves as the president and sole director. |
| In case of incapacitation, the OPC can appoint nominees to carry out necessary duties and responsibilities. |
| An OPC is required to include “OPC” in its name to signify its status. |
This new provision offers entrepreneurs greater flexibility in establishing and managing their own businesses. It eliminates the need to find additional incorporators and allows individuals to take full control of their corporations. Whether you are a freelancer, consultant, or small business owner, the OPC framework provides a streamlined and efficient option for incorporation.
No Minimum Capitalization Requirement
The Revised Corporation Code has brought about significant changes in the requirements for corporations, including the removal of the minimum capitalization requirement. Previously, companies were required to have a specific percentage of subscribed capital paid-up at incorporation or a minimum authorized capital stock. However, under the new code, stock corporations are no longer obliged to maintain a minimum capital, unless specified by special laws.
This change provides businesses with more flexibility in terms of capitalization, allowing them to allocate their resources more efficiently and adapt to dynamic market conditions. It eliminates the burden of meeting a predetermined capital threshold, enabling companies to focus on their core operations and growth strategies.
It’s important to note that even without a minimum capital requirement, companies should still consider their capital needs based on their business model, industry, and growth plans. Adequate capitalization remains crucial for sustaining operations, attracting investors, and complying with other regulatory requirements.
| Comparison | Previous Requirements | Revised Requirements |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum Capitalization | Required | Not required, unless specified by special laws |
| Subscribed Capital Paid-Up | Specific percentage required at incorporation | No specific percentage requirement |
| Authorized Capital Stock | Minimum authorized capital stock required | No minimum authorized capital stock |
With the removal of the minimum capitalization requirement, businesses have more freedom to allocate their resources according to their specific needs and goals. This change promotes a more inclusive and flexible business environment, allowing startups and small enterprises to establish and grow their operations without the burden of meeting stringent capital requirements.
By eliminating the minimum capitalization requirement, the Revised Corporation Code encourages entrepreneurship and innovation, fostering a conducive landscape for business development and investment. This change reflects the government’s commitment to creating a dynamic and competitive business ecosystem that attracts both local and foreign investors.
Perpetual Existence of Corporations
Eliminating the Constraints of a 50-Year Life Limit
With the implementation of the Revised Corporation Code, corporations in the Philippines no longer have a mandatory 50-year life span or corporate term. This significant change allows corporations to exist indefinitely, offering the potential for perpetual existence.
Previously, corporations were subject to a predetermined life term, after which they were required to undergo a renewal process. However, the removal of this limitation provides new opportunities for businesses to thrive without the constant concern of expiration.
This change applies not only to newly incorporated companies but also extends to existing corporations that were established under the previous regulations. Existing corporations now have the option to transition to perpetual existence if the majority of shareholders vote in favor of it.
Certain corporations may still prefer to maintain their original life term due to specific business strategies or preferences. In such cases, corporations can choose to retain their predetermined life span by indicating it in their Articles of Incorporation.
Ensuring Enduring Success and Adaptability
Perpetual existence affords corporations the opportunity to focus on long-term growth strategies, building upon their established brand reputation, and fostering lasting relationships with stakeholders. It allows businesses to expand their operations over time, accessing new markets and adapting to evolving industry trends.
The removal of the 50-year life limit empowers corporations to pursue continuous innovation, strengthen their presence in the market, and explore new avenues for revenue generation. Companies can now plan for the long term with confidence, knowing that their existence is not bound by an arbitrary timeline.
Moreover, the ability to change the life term of a corporation provides flexibility for businesses to adjust their strategic objectives as circumstances evolve. Corporations can adapt their life span to align with changing market dynamics, capitalizing on emerging opportunities and ensuring their longevity.
Determining the Life Term: A Shareholder’s Decision
The decision to transition to perpetual existence or maintain a specific life term lies within the hands of the shareholders. By voting in favor of the desired course of action, shareholders can redefine the future trajectory of the corporation.
| New Corporations | Existing Corporations | |
|---|---|---|
| Voting Outcome | Perpetual Existence | Retain or Change Life Term |
| Advantages | – Long-term growth strategies | – Alignment with strategic objectives |
| – Enhanced brand reputation | – Confidence in enduring success | |
| – Adaptability to market changes | – Flexibility in planning |
The choice regarding the life term of a corporation can profoundly impact its future viability and success. It is essential for stakeholders to carefully consider the long-term implications of their decision and align it with the corporation’s goals and aspirations.
“The removal of the 50-year life limit grants corporations the gift of perpetual existence, enabling them to flourish without the constraints of time. Shareholders possess the power to determine the corporation’s future, shaping its destiny for lasting success and prosperity.”
Foreign Investment-Friendly Provisions
The Revised Corporation Code of the Philippines introduces several provisions that are favorable to foreign investors and multinational companies looking to establish a presence in the country. One significant change is the removal of the requirement for a majority of the board of directors in a corporation to be residents of the Philippines. This amendment opens up opportunities for foreign investors to have more flexibility and control in their business operations.
Previously, the Corporation Code mandated that a majority of the directors must be residents of the Philippines, which could pose challenges for foreign investors who wanted to establish and govern their businesses in the country. However, with the removal of this requirement, foreign investors can now have more freedom in selecting their board members, ensuring that the best individuals are appointed to drive the company’s success.
It’s important to note that while the residency requirement for directors has been lifted, the Treasurer of the corporation must still be a resident of the Philippines. This ensures that there is an individual with local knowledge and expertise handling financial matters in compliance with Philippine regulations.
This change in the Revised Corporation Code is a positive development for foreign investors and multinational companies. It aligns with the government’s efforts to attract more foreign direct investments and promote business growth in the Philippines. With the flexibility to appoint directors without the residency requirement, businesses can now access a wider pool of talent and expertise, allowing for more efficient decision-making and strategic planning.
Foreign investors and multinational companies can take advantage of these foreign investment-friendly provisions to establish and expand their operations in the Philippines. By complying with the Revised Corporation Code’s requirements, businesses can navigate the local regulatory landscape more easily and position themselves for long-term success in this dynamic market.
SEC Moving Towards Online Filings
The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is adapting to the digital age by implementing an online system for processing corporate registrations, incorporations, notices, and other forms of submissions. This shift towards online filings aims to simplify administrative processes and bring convenience to businesses interacting with the SEC. Gone are the days of manual paperwork and lengthy queues. With the new SEC online system, companies can now submit their documents digitally, saving time and effort.
This move aligns with the evolving landscape of business operations and the increasing reliance on digital platforms. By embracing online corporate filings, the SEC is making it easier for entrepreneurs, business owners, and foreign investors to comply with regulatory requirements and stay updated on their corporate paperwork.
The benefits of the SEC online system are numerous. Businesses can now submit their documents from anywhere, anytime, eliminating the need for physical presence. This not only saves time but also reduces costs associated with transportation and logistics. Moreover, digital submissions provide a more organized and efficient process, as documents can be stored electronically and easily retrieved when needed. With real-time tracking and notifications, businesses can stay informed about the status of their filings and address any issues promptly.
The SEC’s move towards digitalization is a significant step towards improving regulatory processes and fostering a business-friendly environment. By leveraging technology and embracing online corporate filings, the SEC is promoting transparency, efficiency, and accessibility in the corporate landscape of the Philippines. Businesses can now focus their time and resources on growth and innovation, knowing that the process of compliance is easier and more streamlined.
In conclusion, the implementation of the SEC online system for digital submissions signifies a positive change in the way businesses interact with the regulatory authority. This digital transformation not only modernizes administrative processes but also empowers businesses to navigate the regulatory landscape with ease and confidence. With the SEC’s commitment to online corporate filings, the future of business registration and compliance in the Philippines is more seamless, efficient, and user-friendly.
Electronic and Remote Communications for Stockholder Meetings
Under the Revised Corporation Code, corporations can now leverage the power of electronic communication to streamline and enhance stockholder meetings. This enables companies to utilize email invitations and other digital platforms to communicate with their stockholders, making the process more efficient and convenient for everyone involved.
One of the key benefits of electronic communication is the ability for stockholders to participate in meetings remotely or in absentia. This means that stockholders no longer need to be physically present at the meeting location to have their voices heard and votes counted. Instead, they can cast their votes and provide input through electronic means, subject to the internal governance rules established by the company.
Implementing electronic and remote communication methods for stockholder meetings can significantly enhance corporate transparency and engagement. It allows for greater inclusivity, enabling stockholders from different locations to actively participate in decision-making processes and exercise their rights as shareholders.
The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is currently working on establishing the necessary mechanisms to effectively implement these provisions of the Revised Corporation Code. This ensures that the electronic communication systems put in place adhere to the highest standards of security and reliability, protecting the integrity of the stockholder meetings and maintaining trust in corporate governance practices.
With the introduction of electronic and remote communications for stockholder meetings, corporations in the Philippines can embrace technological advancements to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of their corporate governance processes. By leveraging the power of electronic communication, companies can foster greater engagement, transparency, and shareholder participation, ultimately driving the success and sustainability of their organizations.
Flexible Location for Stockholder Meetings
The Revised Corporation Code recognizes the importance of flexibility when it comes to the location of stockholder meetings. Unlike the previous regulations that required meetings to be held exclusively at the main office of the company, the new code allows for meetings to be conducted in other locations within the same city or municipality, if it is impractical to convene at the main office.
This provision offers significant benefits for corporations and their stakeholders. It acknowledges the diverse nature of businesses and the logistical challenges that may arise in gathering all stockholders at a single location. With the flexibility to choose alternative meeting venues, companies can ensure broader participation and smoother proceedings.
Whether it is a large corporation with multiple branches or a small business with limited space, the Revised Corporation Code promotes inclusivity and accessibility by allowing stockholder meetings to take place in venues that better suit the needs of the participants.
By incorporating this flexibility, corporations can enhance stockholder engagement and promote a collaborative environment. It also creates opportunities for businesses to explore innovative meeting formats and locations that may foster more productive discussions and decision-making processes.
The Advantages of Flexible Meeting Locations:
- Increased convenience for stockholders
- Greater participation and engagement
- Improved access and accessibility
- Enhanced collaboration and cooperation
Utilizing Technology for Versatile Stockholder Meetings
In this digital age, technology enables even greater flexibility in stockholder meetings. Virtual meetings, webinars, and video conferences can be utilized to connect stockholders from different locations, ensuring meaningful participation and reducing travel constraints.
With the Revised Corporation Code’s recognition of electronic communication methods, such as email invitations, corporations can embrace digital solutions to facilitate stockholder meetings. Advanced online platforms and voting systems can further streamline the meeting process and provide a secure and efficient means for stockholders to cast their votes remotely.
Embracing these technological advancements not only matches the needs of modern businesses but also enhances the overall efficiency and effectiveness of stockholder meetings.
“The flexibility provided by the Revised Corporation Code allows corporations to adapt to the changing landscape of business and technology while ensuring that stockholders’ voices are heard.”
| Benefits of Flexible Meeting Locations | Benefits of Technological Solutions |
|---|---|
| Increased convenience for stockholders | Efficient and secure remote voting capabilities |
| Greater participation and engagement | Enhanced accessibility for stockholders |
| Improved access and accessibility | Streamlined meeting process |
| Enhanced collaboration and cooperation | Reduced travel costs and constraints |
Emergency Board for Quorum Requirements
The Revised Corporation Code introduces the concept of an Emergency Board to address issues related to meeting quorum requirements. In situations where a board meeting cannot achieve quorum due to unplanned absences or vacancies, an Emergency Board can be created to temporarily fill the vacant positions. This ensures that vital decisions can still be made and the business operations can continue without delay.
The Emergency Board serves as a temporary solution until the regular board members can resume their duties or new members are appointed. It allows for effective decision-making during unforeseen circumstances, ensuring that the corporation can function and progress despite unexpected challenges.
The establishment of an Emergency Board should be promptly communicated to the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to maintain transparency and legal compliance. Reporting this action to the SEC helps in upholding corporate governance and prevents any potential conflicts or confusion regarding the composition of the board.
Conclusion
The Corporation Code of the Philippines plays a crucial role in regulating corporate entities and establishing guidelines for doing business in the country. Understanding the provisions and changes introduced by the Revised Corporation Code is essential for entrepreneurs, business owners, and foreign investors looking to establish and manage companies in the Philippines.
Compliance with the code ensures the legal and ethical operation of businesses, safeguarding both the interests of stakeholders and the overall business environment. By adhering to the Corporation Code and Philippine corporate regulations, companies can navigate the intricate legal landscape, mitigate risks, and foster a transparent and accountable business culture.
Furthermore, by staying updated on the provisions and changes within the Corporation Code, businesses can optimize their operations and take advantage of the opportunities presented by the Revised Corporation Code. This includes the option to establish One-Person Corporations, the removal of minimum capitalization requirements, and the implementation of online filings, providing greater ease and flexibility in conducting business in the Philippines.
In summary, the Corporation Code of the Philippines serves as a roadmap for businesses operating in the country, ensuring compliance with legal requirements and fostering a fair and competitive business environment. By embracing the regulations and upholding corporate governance standards, businesses can thrive, contribute to the economic growth of the Philippines, and achieve long-term success.
FAQ
What is the Corporation Code of the Philippines?
The Corporation Code of the Philippines is a legal framework that governs corporations in the country. It provides guidelines and regulations for incorporating and managing businesses.
What are the criminal law principles in the Philippines?
In the Philippines, criminal laws are strictly construed against the state and liberally in favor of the accused. Unless an act is explicitly defined and punished by the penal code or special penal law, no criminal liability is incurred.
What are the penalties for violations of the Corporation Code?
Violations of the Corporation Code can lead to fines ranging from PHP 10,000 to PHP 1,000,000. In some cases, the dissolution of the corporation may also be considered. It’s important to note that liability for these offenses is separate from any other administrative, civil, or criminal liability under the Code and other laws.
What are the changes introduced by the Revised Corporation Code?
The Revised Corporation Code introduced various changes to enhance the efficiency and accessibility of doing business in the Philippines. These changes include the creation of One-Person Corporations, the removal of minimum capitalization requirements, the allowance for corporations to exist indefinitely, and the relaxation of residency requirements for directors.
Are there penalties for violating any provision of the Revised Corporation Code?
Specific penalties or sanctions provided within a particular provision of the Revised Corporation Code should take precedence over the general criminal penalty under Section 170. The Revised Corporation Code aims to clarify which violations are subject to criminal penalties and which are subject to civil remedies.
Is malice required to establish criminal liability under the Corporation Code?
In Philippine jurisdiction, a conviction under the criminal penalty provisions of the Corporation Code would be challenging without establishing malice or the absence of good faith. The specific provisions of the Code often provide remedies or civil sanctions for particular offenses.
What is the One-Person Corporation (OPC)?
The One-Person Corporation (OPC) is a new type of corporation introduced by the Revised Corporation Code. It allows a single individual to establish and manage a corporation, with the sole incorporator also serving as the president and sole director.
Are corporations still required to have a minimum capitalization?
The Revised Corporation Code removed the previous minimum capitalization requirement for corporations. Companies are no longer obliged to have a specific percentage of subscribed capital paid-up at incorporation or a minimum authorized capital stock.
How long can corporations exist under the Revised Corporation Code?
The Revised Corporation Code eliminated the mandatory 50-year life span for corporations. Now, corporations can exist indefinitely with perpetual existence. Existing corporations can still maintain their original life term if the majority of shareholders vote to do so. Corporations can also specify the life term in their Articles of Incorporation.
Are there residency requirements for directors of a corporation?
The Revised Corporation Code removes the requirement for a majority of the board of directors in a corporation to be residents of the Philippines. However, the Treasurer of the corporation must still be a resident of the Philippines.
What are the changes related to corporate filings and communications?
The Revised Corporation Code mandates the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to develop an online system for processing corporate registrations, incorporations, notices, and other forms of submissions. Corporations can also utilize electronic communication methods for stockholder meetings and allow remote voting, subject to the company’s internal governance rules.
Can stockholder meetings take place in locations other than the main office?
The Revised Corporation Code provides flexibility regarding the location of stockholder meetings. While previous regulations required meetings to take place in the main office of the company, the new code allows meetings to be held in other locations within the city or municipality of the company if it is not practicable to convene at the main office.
What is an Emergency Board?
The Revised Corporation Code addresses issues related to meeting quorum requirements by introducing the concept of an Emergency Board. In situations where a board meeting cannot achieve quorum due to unplanned absences or vacancies, an Emergency Board can be created to fill the positions temporarily. The SEC must be immediately informed about the establishment of an Emergency Board.
Source Links
- https://map.org.ph/navigating-the-criminalized-corporate-governance-provisions-of-the-revised-corporation-code/
- https://www.bworldonline.com/opinion/2022/03/07/434342/navigating-the-criminalized-corporate-governance-provisions-of-the-revised-corporation-code/
- https://cloudcfo.ph/blog/corporate/signed-sealed-delivered-the-revised-corporation-code-of-the-philippines-has-arrived-how-might-it-affect-your-business
Add comment